Testimony
Joint Public Hearing: Federal Lending Changes in Higher Education
Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education and Assembly Standing Committee on Banks
Social work is a profession. Students need support now more than ever as federal lending cuts take effect this semester for Master of Social Work (MSW) and Doctor of Social Work (DSW) pathways.
Thank you to Assemblywoman Alicia Hyndman, Chair of Higher Education, and Assemblyman Clyde Vanel, Chair of Banks, for hosting this timely hearing.
Watch the full hearing here:
Watch the full hearing
Download the testimony (PDF)
Key points
- The federal change: MSW and DSW degrees were moved out of the “professional” category for federal loans. New graduate borrowing is capped at $20,500 a year ($100,000 total) instead of $50,000 a year ($200,000 total), and Grad PLUS loans are eliminated.
- The need: New York already has social work shortages, in New York City schools and across rural counties.
- Request 1: A State-funded scholarship for social work students, administered by NASW-NY on a high need basis.
- Request 2: A bill next session to make the New York State Licensed Social Worker Loan Forgiveness Program easier to access.
The National Association of Social Workers, New York Chapter (NASW-NY) represents the 61,000 social workers in New York and over 6,000 members. NASW NY urges New York to respond to federal lending changes for social work students through a scholarship to recruit and retain more providers and through increasing accessibility to the current New York State Licensed Social Worker Loan Forgiveness Program (LSWLF) administered through the Higher Education Services Corporation (HESC)1.
In November 2025, the Federal Department of Education removed the MSW and DSW degrees from the category of "professional," to "graduate2." After a brief comment period of slightly longer than a month and nearly 20,000 comments, the rule was placed into effect less than a year later, adversely affecting new students entering social work programs this fall. Thankfully, students already receiving loans were not affected. New students are now faced with a situation that may leave them to consider a different career and degree path entirely.
Under the preexisting program, graduate students could access two types of federal student loans, regardless of the type of graduate degree they chose to pursue: (1) Direct Unsubsidized Loans, which allowed borrowing up to a capped annual and aggregate amount, and (2) Grad PLUS loans, which allowed borrowing up to the full cost of attendance, serving as a financial backstop to cover whatever the Direct Unsubsidized Loans did not. The reconciliation act—known colloquially as the “Working Families Tax Cuts Act” or the “One Big Beautiful Bill Act” (“Act”)—imposed new borrowing limits on Direct Unsubsidized Loans and eliminated altogether the Grad PLUS loans. Going forward, prospective students who need additional loan assistance for any graduate degree are burdened by new terms and higher interest rates, and are not eligible for federal public service loan forgiveness programs.
Further, the Act imposed different borrowing limits for Direct Unsubsidized Loans depending on the type of degree the student chooses to pursue, adding a new distinction between students enrolled in a “graduate” vs “professional” degree program.
Graduate students will be limited to borrow only up to $20,500 annually ($100,000 in aggregate), whereas “professional” students will be permitted to borrow up to $50,000 annually ($200,000 in aggregate).
These new federal cuts imposed on social workers could not have come at a worse time. Mental health and social services sector report workforce gaps in both rural and urban areas. In New York City specifically, per a report from the NYC Comptroller, 40% of New York City high school students report persistent sadness or hopelessness3. Looking at the school system in particular, where social workers serve an integral role in supporting students social, emotional, and academic development. It was found that New York Public School students are 21 times more likely to seek mental health services at school than at community clinics. Despite this discovery, more than 70% of schools do not reach the 1:250 national recommended ratio for social worker staffing and an estimated 88,000 English Language Learners students have no access to a bilingual mental health staff members at all. There are additional shortages for guidance counselor and school psychologist staffing, exposing the persistent gap in services, that reach every stage of an individual’s life in relation to behavior health services.
In Comparing one county in the Boroughs, Bronx County, and one county Upstate, Otsego County, both counties fall below the recommended ratio for service providers to population. In 2019, Bronx county had 1,016 social workers to the total population 1,418,1874. After COVID-19 in 2023, Bronx county saw a rise of 171 social workers. To translate those workforce numbers to real world effects, Bronx county saw 1,500 mental health Emergency Room (ER) visits per 100,000 of the population in 2019 and did see a decrease to the ER visits by 155 in 2023, showing small but impactful improvements to preventative measures by the increase in social workers. Visit rates were highest among males, young adults ages 18 to 24, Black adults, and residents of neighborhoods with very high poverty5. We commend the State’s recent investments in mental health, which are beginning to make a difference after years of stigma and neglect, but the work cannot end now.
Rural counties have also been faced with provider shortages for decades now, with provider-to-population ratios far below the state average of 1:310. Ratios of 1:500 or more are common, with some areas approaching 1:1,0006. Members have communicated to NASW NY Policy staff that they are not able to retire, because there is no one to replace them. Counties report widespread vacancies in psychiatry, nursing, clinical, peer support, and direct care roles. These shortages lead to gaps in care, which create long waitlists, lack of continuity of services, and closures of inpatient and detox programs.
According to the New York State Association for Rural Health, accessibility failure is strongly exhibited in inpatient behavioral health and crisis services. Many families living in rural areas report months-long waits for psychiatric or substance use treatment beds, sometimes resorting to children to board in emergency departments for days while awaiting placement7. Rural youth and community members deserve access to care, and it can be incredibly isolating to not have that access. In analyzing Otsego County, NY, in 2019, there were 53 social workers for 60,135 population and by 2023, eight more social workers moved into communities in the County. In Cherry Valley, New York, where I attended school, there were zero social workers. In the neighboring town, Richfield Springs, there were zero social workers. Meaning there are two school systems alone, that do not have a school social worker to support students. We hope to increase the provider pool and to invest in the current programs that already exist to recruit and retain social workers and other providers to provide incentive to move to a critical shortage area. Just because there are no careers for social workers in these towns, does not mean the community is not feeling the effects of the vacancy.
I am taking time today to talk about the social work workforce because they are the leading provider of mental health services in the State, but they are also in social services agencies, helping our elderly, counseling someone you love from a dangerous substance use disorder that has altered their life, helping a family navigate fears of family separation, helping ensure a patient discharges from the hospital and is able to fully thrive in their life, and being a life raft for people going through some of their hardest moments. Social workers are sown into every fabric of our community. But they are often not met with value and prioritization, which is what we work towards today. Social workers are highly trained, complete years of education, 3,000 or sometimes more hours of supervision, and measure their competency through exams and by meeting licensure requirement, which are governed in New York by the New York State Education Department (NYSED).
New York prides themselves on having some of the strongest licensure laws in the Nation, and with that high standard which we hold to quality of services, we need to recognize that is only delivered by credible, educated, and vetted professionals. Social Work is a profession. And everything must be done to work towards the effort of recruiting and retaining a strong workforce to meet the demands of the State’s mental health crisis.
Social work students are making sacrifices by entering the social work profession. They are devoting their lives to public service, to put others first, to abide by a guiding Code of Ethics, and they do so, because they love the work. To obtain licensure, social work students must complete their MSW degree. Not every individual entering the profession is able to receive free education or scholarships, and certainly not every individual has the privilege to take out a high-interest loan or pay out-of-pocket. That is why, to respond to the moment, we are asking New York to step in and fund scholarships for social work students.
NASW NY requests funding $1.6 million, which will provide $40,000 to 40,000 students. NASW NY has the foundation to be able to administer the scholarship, on a high need basis. This will meet the urgency, to ensure social work students can remain in school. Students had to unexpectedly plan for this increased burden and a scholarship will create a pipeline for more providers to graduate. This will also help the issue that social worker’s often graduate with high debt, with the average debt being over $60,000 according to the 2024 NASW NYS Loan Forgiveness Survey. We will also be introducing a bill next session to increase accessibility for the New York State Social Worker Loan Forgiveness Program which imposes unnecessary restrictions on eligibility and is denying social workers performing critical work in the field, in counties designated as a critical shortage area for mental health services. Reasons for denial include that their agency is not registered on the Health Resources Services Administration (HRSA) registry. Not every agency is knowledgeable of the need to apply for a designation such as this, leading this program to not reach the very people it is meant to serve. NASW NY also asserts the program should include MSWs, who perform vital services. With the social work profession losing key support, we believe these policy changes will keep social workers afloat, while the work to reverse this action continues at the federal level.
Hear from an MSW student how these changes will impact them:
“As a low-income MSW student at SUNY Plattsburgh, the $20,000 loan cap puts my education at risk. With the cap, I’ll have to come up with $15,000 out of pocket or take on loans from another provider, who often charge higher interest and offer fewer protections. I’m studying to serve people in need, and I shouldn’t have to choose between finishing my degree and financial stability.”
We truly appreciate the work the Legislature and Governor Kathy Hochul have done to support social workers and now, we hope that you respond to this moment with urgency to ensure social work students do not lose the opportunity to serve the community. NASW NY looks forward to your partnership on this issue.